Systems · Updated Oct 14, 2026

PlayStation 4

Offer ranges run from the suggested offer up to the no-deal price, using the better way to sell each copy: the instant buyer, or eBay (tagged, our estimate after fees). Land a copy in that range and it's a flip.

Winners 2

GameSignalOffer range (suggested → no deal)
LooseMissing manualComplete in box
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Blue Flip $16–20$16–20$19–23 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Camo Red Flip $20–28$20–28$20–28

Maybes 52

GameSignalOffer range (suggested → no deal)
LooseMissing manualComplete in box
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Camo Green Maybe $15–19$15–19$18–21 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Red Black Maybe $11–14$11–14$11–14
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Jet Black Maybe $16–20$16–20$30–40 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Crystal Red Maybe $20–28$20–28$20–29 eBay
NHL 20 Maybe $2 eBay$2$2–3 eBay
Destiny: The Taken King Legendary Edition Maybe $1–2 eBay$0$2 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Gold Maybe $12–15$12–15$25–31 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Sunset Orange Maybe $25–33$25–33$25–33
Call of Duty Advanced Warfare Maybe $3 eBay$1$3 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Wave Blue Maybe $16–20$16–20$19–23 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - The Last of Us Part II Maybe $30–42$30–42$45–58 eBay
Dragon Age: Inquisition Maybe $3 eBay$1$3–4 eBay
Star Wars Battlefront II Maybe $2–3 eBay$0$3–4 eBay
WWE 2K19 Maybe $5–6 eBay$3–4$5–6 eBay
Sword Art Online: Lost Song Maybe $4–5 eBay$2$4–5 eBay
Madden NFL 25 Maybe $9–11 eBay$9–11$10–12 eBay
Uncharted 4 Maybe $3–4 eBay$0$3–4 eBay
Grand Theft Auto V Maybe $3–4 eBay$2$6–7 eBay
Mass Effect Andromeda Maybe $3–4 eBay$0$4–5 eBay
WWE 2k18 Maybe $3–4 eBay$1$5–7 eBay
Monster Hunter: World Maybe $3–4 eBay$0$5–6 eBay
Call of Duty Modern Warfare Maybe $3–4 eBay$0$3–4 eBay
Batman: Arkham Knight Maybe $3–4 eBay$1$5–6 eBay
Persona 5 Strikers Maybe↑40% CIB $3–4 eBay$0$5–7 eBay
Fallout 4: GOTY Edition Maybe $5–6 eBay$3$5–7 eBay
Dying Light Maybe $4–5 eBay$2$5–6 eBay
Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare Maybe $4–5 eBay$0$4–5 eBay
Rory McIlroy PGA Tour Maybe $4–5 eBay$2$6–7 eBay
Fallout 4 Maybe $5–6 eBay$2$5–7 eBay
Until Dawn Maybe $4–5 eBay$0$6–7 eBay
WWE 2K16 Maybe $4–5 eBay$2$7–8 eBay
Sonic Forces Maybe $5–6 eBay$1$5–6 eBay
Marvel Spiderman Maybe $7–8 eBay$3–4$7–8 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Gran Turismo Maybe $25–33$25–33$35–43 eBay
Tales of Zestiria Maybe $6–7 eBay$2$6–7 eBay
Call of Duty: WWII Standard Edition Maybe $4–6 eBay$0$5–6 eBay
WWE 2K15 Maybe $5–7 eBay$3$6–8 eBay
Horizon: Zero Dawn Complete Edition Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$5–7 eBay
Call of Duty: Black Ops III Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$7–8 eBay
Call of Duty: Black Ops IV Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$7–8 eBay
God of War Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$6–8 eBay
The Last of Us Remastered Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$5–6 eBay
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain Maybe $5–6 eBay$0$5–6 eBay
Grand Theft Auto V [Premium Edition] Maybe $5–6 eBay$2$6–7 eBay
Star Wars Battlefront II: Elite Trooper Deluxe Edition Maybe $6–7 eBay$3$8–10 eBay
The Jackbox Party Pack Maybe $6–7 eBay$3$7–9 eBay
Playstation 4 Camera Maybe $12–14 eBay$9–11$13–16 eBay
Call of Duty Ghosts Maybe $7–8 eBay$3$7–9 eBay
Mega Man 11 Maybe $5–6 eBay$2$7–9 eBay
Maglam Lord Maybe $6–7 eBay$3$8–10 eBay
Guitar Hero Live (Game Only) Maybe $5–7 eBay$0$8–10 eBay
Red Dead Redemption 2 Maybe $5–7 eBay$0$6–8 eBay

Losers 73

GameSignalOffer range (suggested → no deal)
LooseMissing manualComplete in box
Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy No spread $7–8 eBay$2$7–8 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Magma Red No spread $14–18 eBay$11–14$20–24 eBay
NEO: The World Ends with You No spread $7–9 eBay$3$8–9 eBay
Kamiwaza: Way of the Thief No spread $7–8 eBay$2$7–9 eBay
Nobunaga's Ambition: Sphere of Influence - Ascension No spread $6–7 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Nobunaga's Ambition: Sphere of Influence No spread $6–7 eBay$0$7–8 eBay
Persona 5: Steelbook Edition No spread $7–8 eBay$3$8–10 eBay
Star Ocean: Integrity and Faithlessness No spread $6–7 eBay$2$7–9 eBay
Disgaea 5: Alliance of Vengeance No spread $7–8 eBay$3$10–12 eBay
The Last of Us Part II No spread $8–10 eBay$3$8–10 eBay
Kingdom Hearts: Melody of Memory No spread $8–10 eBay$4–5$9–12 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Electric Purple No spread $20–28 eBay$20–26$30–40 eBay
Hades No spread $7–8 eBay$1$8–9 eBay
Minecraft: Playstation 4 Edition No spread $8–9 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Story of Seasons: Friends of Mineral Town No spread $7–9 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Darth Vader No spread $25–34 eBay$25–33$75–95 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Rose Gold No spread $19–23 eBay$15–19$20–25 eBay
Final Fantasy X|X-2 HD Remaster No spread $7–8 eBay$1$8–9 eBay
Digimon World: Next Order No spread $8–10 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition No spread $8–9 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Disgaea 1 Complete No spread $8–9 eBay$4–5$17–20 eBay
Final Fantasy VII: Remake No spread $7–9 eBay$1$8–10 eBay
Disney Classic Games Collection No spread $8–10 eBay$3$9–11 eBay
Spyro: Reignited Trilogy No spread $8–10 eBay$1$8–10 eBay
NieR Automata: Game of the YoRHa Edition No spread $8–10 eBay$2$8–10 eBay
Romance of the Three Kingdoms XIII No spread $8–10 eBay$3–4$10–12 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Midnight Blue No spread $16–20 eBay$11–14$25–32 eBay
Days Gone No spread $8–10 eBay$1$8–10 eBay
XCOM 2: Collection No spread $10–12 eBay$4–5$17–21 eBay
Minecraft Starter Pack No spread $10–12 eBay$2$13–16 eBay
Poison Control No spread $10–12 eBay$2$11–13 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Uncharted 4 No spread $30–38 eBay$25–33$35–44 eBay
The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel III - Early Enrollment Edition No spread $11–14 eBay$3$13–16 eBay
Romance of the Three Kingdoms XIV No spread $12–14 eBay$3$15–18 eBay
Mercenaries Blaze: Dawn of the Twin Dragons No spread $12–14 eBay$2$15–19 eBay
Shenmue I & II No spread $12–15 eBay$2$13–16 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Crystal Blue No spread $18–22 eBay$7–9$20–27 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - 20th Anniversary No spread $30–41 eBay$25–33$60–74 eBay
Yakuza Remastered Collection No spread $14–17 eBay$3–4$16–19 eBay
Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive Edition No spread $13–16 eBay$2$15–18 eBay
Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Edition No spread $17–20 eBay$5–6$18–22 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Urban Camo No spread $20–25 eBay$7–9$20–26 eBay
PlayStation 4 500GB Black Console No spread $55–71 eBay$55–68$80–100 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Star Wars Battlefront II No spread $25–36 eBay$15–19$30–36 eBay
Atelier Sophie 2: The Alchemist of the Mysterious Dream No spread $18–22 eBay$3$20–25 eBay
Blue Reflection: Second Light No spread $20–27 eBay$5–6$20–27 eBay
Nights of Azure No spread $19–23 eBay$5–6$20–29 eBay
Atelier Ryza 2: Lost Legends & the Secret Fairy No spread $20–25 eBay$2$20–27 eBay
Dongle Only (Guitar Hero Live) No spread $25–32 eBay$7–9$30–37 eBay
Langrisser I & II No spread $25–30 eBay$5–6$25–32 eBay
Nights of Azure 2: Bride of the New Moon No spread $20–29 eBay$3$25–30 eBay
PlayStation 4 Slim 1TB Gold Console No spread $85–109 eBay$80–100$190–243 eBay
Minecraft: Story Mode Complete Adventure No spread $45–59 eBay$30–37$50–63 eBay
The Legend of Nayuta: Boundless Trails - Deluxe Edition No spread $35–44 eBay$10–13$35–46 eBay
The Legend of Heroes: Trails to Azure - Deluxe Edition No spread $30–37 eBay$5–6$30–42 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - 500 Million No spread $55–72 eBay$30–38$60–77 eBay
PlayStation 4 Pro 1TB Black Console No spread $90–111 eBay$65–84$110–142 eBay
Rock Band 4 Jaguar (non-working or cosmetically flawed guitars will be rejected) No spread $50–66 eBay$20–26$55–67 eBay
The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel No spread $40–49 eBay$3–4$50–62 eBay
The Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel II No spread $40–49 eBay$2$50–62 eBay
Rock Band 4 Stratocaster (non-working or cosmetically flawed guitars will be rejected) No spread $50–66 eBay$18–22$55–67 eBay
Rock Band 4 No spread $50–66 eBay$15–19$55–67 eBay
Minecraft: Story Mode - Season 2 No spread $45–59 eBay$10–13$50–63 eBay
PlayStation 4 Pro 1TB Star Wars Battlefront II Console No spread $95–118 eBay$65–80$160–197 eBay
Gravity Rush 2 No spread↑64% loose $65–81 eBay$35–47$75–92 eBay
PlayStation 4 500GB Destiny The Taken King Console No spread $90–109 eBay$50–64$130–161 eBay
Playstation TV No spread $80–100 eBay$25–33$110–134 eBay
PlayStation 4 500GB Batman Arkham Knight Console No spread $100–130 eBay$55–70$240–295 eBay
Playstation 4 Dualshock 4 Controller - Death Stranding No spread $85–105 eBay$25–33$95–120 eBay
Deadpool No spread↑62% loose $90–114 eBay$25–31$95–116 eBay
Star Wars Racer Revenge No spread $140–177 eBay$65–83$170–208 eBay
PlayStation 4 Pro 1TB Spider-Man Console No spread $190–239 eBay$90–113$220–279 eBay
PlayStation 4 Pro 1TB The Last of Us Part II Console No spread $210–260 eBay$110–139$290–353 eBay